| Platinum | Fairport Village Inn |
| Gold | Tapas 177 Lounge |
| Gold | The Gate House |
| Silver | Magnolia's Deli & Cafe |
| Bronze | Dinosaur Bar-B-Que |
| Bronze | Nosh |
| Top Pick | Cobblestone On Main |
| Top Pick | Genesee Brew House |
| Top Pick | Redd |
| Top Pick | The Red Fern |
| Agatina's Restaurant |
