| Platinum | Fairport Village Inn |
| Gold | Tin Cup Social |
| Silver | Bachelors Forum |
| Silver | Blue Barn Cidery |
| Bronze | The Half Pint Pub |
| Top Pick | Irondequoit Beer Company |
| Top Pick | Jack's Extra Fancy |
| Top Pick | Marge's Lakeside Inn |
| Top Pick | Shamrock Jack's |
| Top Pick | The Daily Refresher |
| Top Pick | The Retreat |
