| Platinum | Original Steve's Diner |
| Gold | Highland Park Diner |
| Silver | Jim's On Main |
| Bronze | Mel's Diner |
| Top Pick | Atlas Eats - Irondequoit |
| Top Pick | Jines Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Lakeside Haven Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Parkside Diner |
| Top Pick | Silo Brunch Bar |
| Top Pick | The Village Bakery, Webster |
