| Platinum | Guido's Pasta Villa |
| Gold | Rocky's |
| Silver | Mamma G's |
| Bronze | Salvatore's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Benuccis Contemporary Italian Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Davinci Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Giuseppe's |
| Top Pick | LA Bella Vita |
| Top Pick | Ricci's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rubino's Italian Foods |
