| Platinum | Carbone's Pizzeria |
| Platinum | Pizza Wizard |
| Platinum | Pontillo's Bushnell's Basin |
| Gold | The Gate House |
| Silver | Pizza Chef |
| Silver | Salvatore's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage |
| Bronze | Salty Bread Pizza Cafe |
| Top Pick | 2 Ton Tony's Irondequoit |
| Top Pick | Tom and Nancy S |
