| Platinum | Magnolia's Deli & Cafe |
| Gold | Dell's Market & Deli |
| Silver | Fox's Deli |
| Silver | Rubino's Italian Foods |
| Silver | Salvatore's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Sapori |
| Top Pick | Donnelly's Public House |
| Top Pick | Fairport Village Inn |
| Top Pick | Leaf & Bean Coffee Co |
| Top Pick | Swan Market |
