| Platinum | Rubino's Italian Foods |
| Gold | Trianos Meat Market & Deli |
| Silver | Swan Market |
| Bronze | Palmer's Direct to You Market |
| Top Pick | Costanza Sausage |
| Top Pick | Grass Fed Vegan Butchershop |
| Top Pick | Joe's Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Pettinari's |
| Top Pick | Rochester Public Market |
| Top Pick | Skip's Meat Market |
