| Platinum | Galicia Restaurant |
| Gold | Proiettis Italian Restaurant and Catering |
| Silver | Dell's Market & Deli |
| Silver | Rubino's Italian Foods |
| Bronze | Partyman Catering |
| Bronze | Uncle Buck's Catering Company |
| Top Pick | 2 Ton Tony's Irondequoit |
| Top Pick | Agatina's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Board and Bacon |
| Top Pick | Tavo's Antojitos Y Tequila |
