| Platinum | Rochester Public Market |
| Gold | Market 1892 |
| Silver | Brighton Farmers Market |
| Bronze | Schutt's Apple Mill |
| Top Pick | Aman's Farm & Market |
| Top Pick | Irondequoit Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Kirby's Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Powers Farm Market |
| Top Pick | Sunscape Farms |
| Top Pick | Whittier Fruit Farm |
