| Platinum | The Gate House |
| Gold | Uncle Buck's Catering Company |
| Silver | Kithnos Seafood Market |
| Bronze | Mulconry's Irish Pub and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bill Gray's Seabreeze |
| Top Pick | Blue Ridge Grill |
| Top Pick | Captain Jim's Fish Market |
| Top Pick | Mama Lor's Cafe |
| Top Pick | Polska Chata |
| Top Pick | The Union Tavern |
