| Platinum | Proiettis Italian Restaurant and Catering |
| Gold | Tony D's |
| Silver | Joey's Pasta House |
| Silver | Lemoncello |
| Bronze | Mr. Dominic's at the Lake |
| Top Pick | Agatina's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Fiamma Centro |
| Top Pick | Giuseppe's |
| Top Pick | Guido's Pasta Villa |
| Top Pick | Red Fedele's Brook House Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rubino's Italian Foods |
