| Platinum | Velvet Belly |
| Gold | California Rollin |
| Silver | Taka House - Webster |
| Bronze | Shema Sushi |
| Top Pick | Kobe Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar |
| Top Pick | Next Door by Wegmans |
| Top Pick | Plum House |
| Top Pick | Sushi585 |
| Top Pick | Umai Revolving Sushi |
| Top Pick | Wegmans Market Cafe |
