| Platinum | The Freak Out Flea |
| Gold | Smartypants |
| Silver | A Second Thought Resale Shop |
| Silver | Second Chances Consignment Shoppe |
| Bronze | Rochester Greenovation |
| Top Pick | Fomo |
| Top Pick | Lu's Back Door |
| Top Pick | Once Upon A Child |
| Top Pick | Rochester Greenovation |
| Top Pick | The Salvation Army Thrift Store Rochester, NY |
