| Platinum | Goodwill |
| Gold | Rochester Greenovation |
| Silver | The Shops On West Ridge |
| Bronze | A Second Thought Resale Shop |
| Top Pick | 1st Print Comics |
| Top Pick | Amvets |
| Top Pick | Estate Sales Store |
| Top Pick | SewGreen Rochester |
| Top Pick | The Salvation Army Thrift Store Rochester, NY |
| Top Pick | The Vintage Aesthetic |
