| Platinum | Mahan's Liquor |
| Gold | Lisa's Liquor |
| Silver | Webster Wine & Spirits |
| Bronze | Eastway Liquor |
| Top Pick | Baytowne Wine & Spirits |
| Top Pick | Canal Ponds Liquor |
| Top Pick | Irondequoit Liquor |
| Top Pick | Parkway Discount Wine & Liquor |
| Top Pick | Seabreeze Wine & Spirits |
| Top Pick | Suburban Liquor |
